When you tune in to season three of “Nobody Wants This” sometime later this year, don’t be too surprised if you see Karlie Kloss get a writing credit.
In a recent interview for the Bloomberg Original series “The Circuit,” the 33-year-old Jewish model revealed that she has found the hot rabbi Netflix show extremely relatable. In fact, she has shared some of her own experiences with converting to Judaism with “Nobody Wants This” creator and writer Erin Foster.
“My friend’s actually the writer of the show and I texted her,” Kloss exclaimed, referring to Foster. “I was like, ‘Girl, for season 2, 3, 4, I got more material for you,’ you know, like, ‘Call me.’”
What exact experiences Kloss is referring to, she didn’t say. But perhaps it could include the rumors that her now-husband Joshua Kushner’s brother Jared (yes, that one) referred to Kloss as a “shiksa” and that the Kushner family as a whole refused to meet her for the first six years of her and Josh’s relationship.
The Kushners did, however, finally meet Kloss after she completed the conversion process ahead of getting engaged to Josh in 2018. The couple were later married in a small Jewish ceremony.
“I fell in love with somebody whose faith was a huge part of who he is, and I knew that from the start,” Kloss added about her husband. “And choosing that I wanted it in my life. I’m really proud of that choice.”
Even so, Kloss says she didn’t convert just for her husband. “This is my life and I am an independent, strong woman,” Kloss elaborated for British Vogue in 2019. “It was only after many years of studying and talking with my family and friends and soul searching that I made the decision to fully embrace Judaism in my life and start planning for a future with the man I chose to marry.”
Now, that future includes three children together, Levi Joseph, Elijah Jude and Rae Florence — the latter of whom is named after Joshua’s Holocaust survivor grandmother.
So could a future storyline in “Nobody Wants This” be from Kloss’s life? Potentially! What we know so far about season three is this: Filming wrapped in May 2026 and the season is slated to debut at some point later this year. (Check out these adorable behind-the-scenes photos!) So far, season three guest stars include Sarah Silverman, Erin Foster, Sadie Sandler, Andrew Rannells, Keyla Monterroso Mejia, Steven Weber and Avan Jogia. And based on characters like Rabbi Eden (Silverman), the teacher of Joanne’s intro to Judaism class, and Sebastian (Rannells), Joanne’s intro to Judaism class arch-nemesis, it’s clear that Joanne is at least starting the conversion process.
If a story from Kloss’s own life does eventually make it into the show, all we request is that Karlie Kloss gets her own cameo.
Can we ask? Keep Jewish joy accessible to all. Reader donations help us do just that. Can you help us meet our year-end goals? (We'll love you forever.)
