Follow Kveller
Nov 12 2010

No Toys AND No Circumcision?!

By at 4:55 pm

As seen below in the weekly roundup, San Francisco likes to be the first at things. They were the first city to take on eliminating toys from Happy Meals, and now they are the first city to take on their next target: mohels.

Sort of. Lloyd Schofield, a resident of San Francisco, is proposing to ban circumcision throughout the city. Though the logic behind the proposal has not been fully explored, if the measure were to pass, it would “make it a misdemeanor to circumcise, excise, cut or mutilate the foreskin, testicle or penis of another person who has not attained the age of 18.” I know that there are a fair number of people who think it wrong to induce unnecessary surgery on a person who does not have the ability to consent to it–and our blogger Sarah Tuttle-Singer has thoroughly explored the issue over at Kveller–but if this were to pass, anyone interested in carrying on the Jewish tradition could face a hefty $1,000 fee or up to a year in prison. Oy!

Chances are the bill won’t pass, as Schofield would need to collect 7,168 signatures by April 26, 2011, but Bay-area mohels might want to start thinking about what kind of front organization they can set up to perform the risky business on the down low.

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on Kveller are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy

2 Responses to No Toys AND No Circumcision?!

  1. Lauren says:

    A web-based multimedia project that puts real faces and voices to the current Jewish movement against male infant circumcision. This dynamic site is being created by, for, and about Jewish people with original content and great links to existing web resources.

    Questioning Circumcision — A Jewish Perspective

    An intact Jewish American woman decides to not cut off part her son:

    A cut Jewish man writes a letter to his newborn son:

    Circumcision: A Source of Jewish Pain

  2. JS says:

    So glad this bill IS going to pass. Time to end genital mutilation for all.


Recently on Mayim







Read previous post:
Roundup: Oral Sex, DC Metro, and Expensive Childcare