Follow Kveller
Jan 14 2011

A Parent’s Responsibility: The Tucson Massacre

By at 10:34 am

Jared L. Loughner

It’s hard to remember that he has parents.  It’s hard to imagine him as part of a family.

But Jared Loughner, the 22-year-old man who was recently charged with killing six people and wounding 14 others (including a congresswoman) in Arizona on January 8, does have parents. And based on the brief statement they released to the press, it seems as though Randy and Amy Loughner are just as confused and horrified by their son’s actions as the rest of us.

How do we, as parents, make sense of this senseless violence? It’s certainly tempting to seek out some fault in Loughner’s parents, to create a comforting distance between us and them.  Clearly, they must have failed in ways that we never would, as we would never raise a child who will one day take another life in such a heinous matter.  Right?  Right?

Well, not necessarily.

I’m not going to speculate on the Loughners’ parenting style or their relationship with their son.  Here is what I do know: at some point, our children become independent individuals, beyond our control. Furthermore, the amount of influence we have over who they will become is debatable. It’s easy to lose sight of such obvious truths in the fog of anxiety and hope that clouds the daily life of parenting.  The illusion of control is powerful–if we can’t believe that the right combination of breastmilk, playdates, and affection will guarantee that our child will grow up to be a mensch, then what hope do we have as parents?  And what responsibility do we have for who our child becomes?

Not surprisingly, the Talmud has something to say about this: “A father is obligated to do the following for his son: to circumcise him, to redeem him if he is a first born, to teach him Torah, to find him a wife, and to teach him a trade. Others say: teaching him how to swim as well” (Kiddushin 29a).

While the language is clearly a relic of the time, the message is useful.  As parents, we must introduce our children to a community, provide religious, intellectual, and vocational training, and give them basic survival skills. Interestingly enough, we are not told that we must raise a good person, presumably because such advice would be useless. We can offer our children the best education, nutrition, resources, and support possible, and they may still grow up to make choices that will bewilder, offend, or even horrify us.

What a terrifying thought.

But parenting is nothing if not a leap of faith. We devote years of our lives to the development of our children in hopes that they will make the world a better place. Yet there is much in this world that is beyond our control, and sometimes it just doesn’t work out that way. As President Obama noted in his speech at the Tucson memorial, “We may not be able to stop all evil in the world, but I know that how we treat one another is entirely up to us.”

President Obama’s words echo a familiar quote from the Talmud, which reminds us that while we are not obliged to complete the work, neither are we free to desist from it.  Perhaps that idea applies to parenting as well–although we are not responsible for who our children ultimately become, we must raise them each day as though we are.

Note: The opinions expressed here are the personal views of the author. All comments on Kveller are moderated. Any comment that is offensive or inappropriate will be removed. Privacy Policy

8 Responses to A Parent’s Responsibility: The Tucson Massacre

  1. homeshuling says:

    There was an interesting and tragic piece last week on Salon about one mother’s struggle, and ultimate inability, to procure mental health care for her son, who had a similar profile. More to the point of your piece, there is a reason traditional parents recite the “baruch sheptarani” blessing at a bar mitzvah – a reminder that we must both do our best and recognize that at some point we are no longer in control.

  2. Carla says:

    Bonnie – thank you for your comment. As a clinical social worker, I am always interested in issues related to mental illness. While it seems as though Jared Loughner may have schizophrenia or a related illness, I am reticent to diagnose based on media reports. However, mental illness is just one of many factors which can forever alter the course of our children’s lives… yet, we must still do the best we can as parents. – Carla

  3. Liz says:

    Beautiful and insightful article.

  4. Signe says:

    Well written Carla. Thank you for another great article.

  5. Bonnie says:

    This is beautifully written and thoughtful. I wonder if it makes sense, though, to see Loughner in terms of his own autonomy versus parental influence, when he clearly has serious mental illness. That doesn’t eliminate the moral dimension, but it seems as much a medical question as a moral one.

  6. Hope Kellman says:

    Beautifully written, Carla.

  7. Josette says:

    Absolutely right on.

  8. jos says:

    Wow. Very well said. The last line especially hit home for me. Again: Wow.


Recently on Mayim







Read previous post:
Soap Tastes…Well, Bad